Analysis of criminal law on ecocide: A case study of war in Ukraine
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18800/kawsaypacha.202402.D013Keywords:
Criminal offenses, Harm to health, Safety, Natural environment, Grave consequencesAbstract
While actions leading to environmental degradation already have global consequences threatening the very existence of humanity, the war in Ukraine has once again proved the effectiveness of existing international environmental protection mechanisms. The purpose of this study is to analyze existing international environmental protection mechanisms from the perspective of the possibility of criminalizing the crime of ecocide. Based on the analysis of the domestic law of countries that have incorporated ecocide as a crime, it follows that national approaches to addressing this issue depend on historical conditions and have significant differences. These differences hinder the prosecution of ecocide in the absence of appropriate international legal mechanisms, while the consequences of ecocide cause global damage. An analysis of the state of international regulations has shown that despite the existence of an extensive environmental protection mechanism, it remains imperfect, thus making it impossible to prosecute ecocide unless it is done in connection with war crimes. An assessment of the data presented in the reports on the war in Ukraine shows that participation in relevant international conventions does not in any way guarantee that the aggressor country will not violate its international obligations. It is shown that recognizing ecocide as a crime at the international level remains the only effective means to bring perpetrators to justice. The results of the study can be used to further improve the legal mechanisms for prosecuting ecocide, in teaching legal disciplines, and in further academic research.
Downloads
References
Anisimova, H.; Donets, O.; Shynkarov, O.; Shchonkin, R. & Skliar, I. (2023). Contemporary challenges and threats to national security: environmental and legal aspects. Sigurnost, 65(1), pp. 1-23.
Anisimova, H.; Haltsova, V.; Donets, O.; Samoshchenko, I. & Shynkarov, O. (2023). An environmental and legal component of criminal offenses in conditions of the Russian-Ukrainian international military conflict. European Energy and Environmental Law Review, 32(1), pp. 47-65.
Babakhani, E. (2023). On the effectiveness of restorative justice in the ecocide crime. Vilnius University Open Series, pp. 7-15. https://doi.org/10.15388/PhDStudentsConference.2023.1
Bozkurt, K. (2023). Assessments on the Ukraine-Russia war in the axis of international law and ecocide crimes. Istanbul: Yeditepe Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi, 20(2), pp. 209-228.
Burns, R. (2023). From Meaning to Ecocide: The value of phenomenology for green criminology. Critical Criminology. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-023-09730-8
Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (2022). Resolution “On approval of the procedure for determining damage and losses caused to Ukraine as a result of the armed aggression of the Russian Federation”. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/326-2022-%D0%BF#Text
Chandel, A.; Bhanot, N. & Verma, R. (2023). A Bibliometric Investigation of Ecocide Research: Tracing Trends and Shaping the Future. E3S Web Conferences, 453, 01044. https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202345301044
Chiarini, G. (2022). Ecocide: From the Vietnam war to international criminal jurisdiction? procedural issues in-between environmental science, climate change, and law. Cork Online Law Review, 21, pp. 1-34.
Council of Europe (1979). Convention on the conservation of European wildlife and natural habitats. Retrieved from https://rm.coe.int/1680078aff
Council of Europe (1993). Convention on civil liability for damage resulting from activities dangerous to the environment. Retrieved from https://rm.coe.int/168007c079
Council of Europe (1998). Convention on the protection of the environment through criminal law. Retrieved from https://rm.coe.int/168007f3f4
Council of Europe (2016). Council of Europe landscape convention. Retrieved from https://rm.coe.int/16807b6bc7
Council of Europe (2022a). Recommendation CM/Rec(2022)20 of the Committee of Ministers to member States on human rights and the protection of the environment. Retrieved from https://rm.coe.int/0900001680a83df1
Council of Europe (2022b). The Russian Federation is excluded from the Council of Europe. Retrieved from https://www.coe.int/en/web/portal/-/the-russian-federation-is-excluded-from-the-council-of-europe
Council of Europe (2022c). Council of Europe to draft a new global convention to protect the environment through criminal law. Retrieved from https://www.coe.int/en/web/cdpc/-/council-of-europe-to-draft-a-new-global-convention-to-protect-the-environment-through-criminal-law
Criminal code of the Republic of Armenia (2003) Retrieved from http://www.parliament.am/legislation.php?sel=show&ID=1349&lang=eng
Crook, M.; Short, D. & South, N. (2018). Ecocide, genocide, capitalism and colonialism: Consequences for indigenous peoples and global ecosystems environments. Theoretical Criminology, 22(3), pp. 298-317.
Cusato, E. & Jones, E. (2023). The “imbroglio” of ecocide: A political economic analysis. Leiden Journal of International Law, 37(1), pp. 1-20.
Eichler, L. J. (2020). Ecocide is Genocide: Decolonizing the Definition of Genocide. Genocide Studies and Prevention, 14(2), pp. 104-121.
Espreso Global (2023). Ukraine investigates 271 Russian war crimes against environment. Retrieved from https://global.espreso.tv/ukraine-investigates-271-russian-war-crimes-against-environment
EUAM Ukraine (2023). Ecocide in Ukraine won’t go unpunished. United for Justice. United for Nature. Retrieved from https://www.euam-ukraine.eu/news/ecocide-in-ukraine-won-t-go-unpunished-united-for-justice-united-for-nature/
European Parliament Research Service (2023). Russia’s war in Ukraine: High environmental toll. Retrieved from https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/ATAG/2023/751427/EPRS_ATA(2023)751427_EN.pdf
Fedele, G.; Donatti, C. I.; Bornacelly, I. & Hole, D. G. (2021). Nature-dependent people: Mapping human direct use of nature for basic needs across the tropics. Global Environmental Change, 71, pp. 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2021.102368
Frisso, G. M. (2023). Ecocide: the environment as victim at the International Criminal Court. International Crimes Database. Retrieved from https://www.internationalcrimesdatabase.org/upload/documents/20230308T111040-Ecocide%20-%20The%20Environment%20as%20Victim%20at%20the%20International%20Criminal%20Court%20%5BFINAL%5D.pdf
Galligan, B. P. (2021). Re-theorizing the genocide-ecocide nexus: Raphael Lemkin and ecocide in the Amazon. The International Journal of Human Rights, 26(6), pp. 1004-1031.
Gardashuk, T. (2022). Is Russian aggression in Ukraine Ecocide? Envigogika, 17(1), pp. 1-6.
Haltsova, V. V.; Kharytonov, S. O.; Khramtsov, O. M.; Zhytnyi, O. O. & Vasyliev, A. A. (2021). Criminal law as a means of protecting human rights and freedoms in the modern world. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 28(3), pp. 248-256.
Hausknost, D. & Hammond, M. (2019). Beyond the environmental state? The political prospects of a sustainability transformation. Environmental Politics, 29, pp. 1-16.
International Committee of the Red Cross (2020). Guidelines on the Protection of the Natural Environment in Armed Conflicts. Retrieved from https://www.icrc.org/en/publication/4382-guidelines-protection-natural-environment-armed-conflict
International Criminal Court (1998). Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Retrieved from https://www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/RS-Eng.pdf
Kharytonov, S. O.; Orlovskyi, R. S.; Olha, V.; Kurman, T. V. & Maslova, O. O. (2023). criminal legal protection of the environment: national realities and international standards. European Energy and Environmental Law Review, 32(6), pp. 283-292.
Kowalska, S. (2023). Ecocide: A threat to biological tissue and ecological safety. Veredas do Direito Direito Ambiental e Desenvolvimento Sustentável, 20, pp. 1-15.
Law on Combating Climate Change and Strengthening Resilience to its effects (2021). Retrieved from https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/download/pdf?id=x7Gc7Ys-Z3hzgxO5KgI0zSu1fmt64dDetDQxhvJZNMc
Marcantonio, R. & Fuentes, A. (2023). Environmental violence: a tool for planetary health research. Lancet Planet Health, 7(10), pp. 859-867.
Matwijkiw, A. & Matwijkiw, B. (2023). Business-as-usual barriers for the crime of ecocide: a multidisciplinary maze. Journal of International Criminal Law, 4, pp. 1-27. Retrieved from https://www.jicl.ir/article_172298_546174fb70519dff2a40e1767dd8c3b0.pdf
Mehra, N.; Gholipour, G. & Babakhani, E. (2019). Ecocide: A Crime against sustainable development. Ankara: Ankara Üniversitesi SBF Dergisi.
Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources of Ukraine (2024). Environmental damage from war. Retrieved from https://mepr.gov.ua/topics/novyny/zbytky-dovkillyu-vid-vijny/
Moribe, C. M.; Pereira, F. & França, N. (2023). Ecocide: A new challenge for the international criminal law and for humanity. Journal of International Criminal Law, 4(1), pp. 28-40.
Office of the Prosecutor General (2023). Destruction of the Kakhovka HPP dam. Retrieved from https://t.me/s/pgo_gov_ua/12971
Olivi, L. (2022). The public’s perception of the seriousness of environmental crimes related to environmental pollution and illegal waste trade. a case study of the Province of Brescia, Italy. Journal of illicit Economies and Development, 4(1), pp. 17-33
Orobets, K. (2022). Concept, Signs and Types of Criminal Offence in Legislation and Practice of the US and Ukraine. Pakistan Journal of Criminology, 14(2), pp. 47-62.
Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (2023). Environmental impact of armed conflicts. Resolution 2427(2023). Retrieved from https://pace.coe.int/en/files/31600/html
Parliament of the Republic of Moldova (2002). Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova. Retrieved from https://sherloc.unodc.org/cld/uploads/res/document/criminal-code-of-the-republic-of-moldova_html/Republic_of_Moldova_Criminal_Code.pdf
Pavlova, O.; Kuchynska, I.; Gorbalinskiy, V.; Volodina, O. & Melnychenko, B. B. (2023). The war between Ukraine and Russia as a historical and civilizational aspect. Trames, 27(4), pp. 327-349
Ministry of Justice of Vietnam (1999). Penal Code of Vietnam. Retrieved from https://natlex.ilo.org/dyn/natlex2/r/natlex/fe/details?p3_isn=56207
Robinson, D. (2022). Ecocide – Puzzles and Possibilities. Journal of International Criminal Justice, 20(2), 313-347
Sarliève, M. (2021). Ecocide: Past, Present, and Future Challenges. In W., Leal Filho, A. M., Azul, L., Brandli, A., Lange Salvia., & T., Wall (Eds.). Life on Land. Encyclopedia of the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Cham: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-95981-8_110
SaveEcoBot (2024). Retrieved from https://www.saveecobot.com/features/environmental-crimes
Shatilo, V. A.; Kharytonov, S. O.; Kovbasa, V. M.; Svintsytskyi, A. V. & Lyseiuk, A. M. (2023). Prospects for State and Individual Responsibility in Cases of Aggression in the Context of Russia's Armed Aggression Against Ukraine. International Criminal Law Review, 23(4), pp. 626-641.
Stop Ecocide International (2021). Legal definition of ecocide. Retrieved from https://www.stopecocide.earth/legal-definition
United Nations (1976). United Nations convention on the prohibition of military or any other hostile use of environment modification techniques. Retrieved from https://treaties.un.org/doc/Treaties/1978/10/19781005%2000-39%20AM/Ch_XXVI_01p.pdf
United Nations (1977). Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 relating to the protection of victims of international armed conflicts. Retrieved from https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%201125/volume-1125-I-17512-English.pdf
Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (2001). Criminal Code of Ukraine. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2341-14#Text
Winter, E. (2023). Stop Ecocide International’s Blueprint for Ecocide Is Compromised by Anthropocentrism: A New Architect Must Be Found. Israel Law Review, 57(1), pp. 1-35.
Yaroshenko, O. M.; Anisimova, H. V.; Koliesnik, T. V.; Kaplina, H. A.; Babych, N. O. (2024). National Strategy for a Barrier-Free Environment: Problems, tolerance and implementation. International Social Work, 67(1), pp. 226-241.
